Introduction

The National Council of Educational Research and Training (NCERT) is an autonomous organization responsible for the development and publication of textbooks and educational materials for schools across India. The NCERT textbooks have been a major source of education for millions of students for decades. However, in recent times, there has been a debate on the removal of some Mughal topics from NCERT textbooks. While some argue that it is essential to remove these topics, others believe that it would be a detrimental move.

This article aims to analyze the reasons behind the debate and provide a balanced perspective on the issue.

The Debate

The debate on the removal of Mughal topics from NCERT textbooks is not new. It gained momentum in 2017 when the Rajasthan government directed the NCERT to remove certain chapters on Mughal rulers like Akbar and Aurangzeb from its textbooks. The Rajasthan government argued that these chapters glorify the Mughals and their rule, which is not consistent with the state’s nationalist ideology.

The move was met with criticism from scholars, historians, and educators who argued that the decision was politically motivated and lacked academic merit. They argued that the Mughal era was an important period in Indian history, and the study of Mughal rulers was essential to understand the socio-cultural, political, and economic developments during that time.

However, the debate resurfaced in 2021 when the Ministry of Education set up a committee to review the NCERT textbooks and suggest changes to the curriculum. The committee recommended the removal of some chapters on Mughal rulers, including Akbar and Aurangzeb, from the textbooks. The committee argued that these chapters are not relevant to the present times and do not contribute to the holistic development of the students.

The Positive Perspective

The recommendation of the committee to remove some chapters on Mughal rulers from NCERT textbooks has sparked a heated debate. However, there are some positive aspects to this move that need to be considered.

Firstly, the removal of these chapters will help in reducing the burden of the syllabus on students. The NCERT textbooks are already voluminous, and the addition of irrelevant and unnecessary content only adds to the workload of the students. By removing some chapters on Mughal rulers, the NCERT can reduce the syllabus, allowing students to focus on more relevant and important topics.

Secondly, the removal of these chapters will ensure that the textbooks are free from political biases and prejudices. The Mughal rulers have been a subject of political debate, and their portrayal in textbooks has often been influenced by political ideologies. By removing some chapters on Mughal rulers, the NCERT can ensure that the textbooks are free from any political biases and prejudices, allowing students to form an objective view of history.

Thirdly, the removal of these chapters will not have a significant impact on the overall understanding of Indian history. The Mughal era was undoubtedly an important period in Indian history, but the study of Mughal rulers is not the only way to understand it. Indian history is vast and encompasses many other important periods and rulers, such as the Mauryan Empire, the Gupta Empire, and the Maratha Empire, to name a few. By removing some chapters on Mughal rulers, the NCERT can provide a more holistic understanding of Indian history.

The Negative Perspective

While there are some positive aspects to the removal of some Mughal topics from NCERT textbooks, there are also some negative aspects that need to be considered.

Firstly, the removal of these chapters will result in the loss of valuable historical information. The Mughal era was a significant period in Indian history, and the study of Mughal rulers provides valuable insights into the socio-cultural, political, and economic developments during that time. By removing some chapters on Mughal rulers, students will miss out on this crucial information, which may affect their overall understanding of Indian history.

Secondly, the removal of these chapters may result in the distortion of history. The Mughal era was a period of great cultural exchange and integration, and the study of Mughal rulers is essential to understand the synthesis of different cultures that took place during that time. By removing some chapters on Mughal rulers, the NCERT may distort the history of that period, leading to a one-sided and incomplete understanding of Indian history.

Thirdly, the removal of these chapters may lead to the erosion of secular values. The Mughal rulers, particularly Akbar, were known for their efforts to promote religious tolerance and harmony. The study of their rule can help students understand the importance of secular values in Indian society. By removing some chapters on Mughal rulers, the NCERT may inadvertently undermine the values of religious tolerance and harmony, which are essential for the multicultural and pluralistic fabric of Indian society.

The Way Forward

The debate on the removal of some Mughal topics from NCERT textbooks is complex, and it is essential to find a balanced approach to the issue. Here are some recommendations for the way forward:

Firstly, it is essential to ensure that the decision to remove or retain certain chapters in NCERT textbooks is based on academic merit and not influenced by political biases or ideologies. The NCERT should consult with scholars, historians, and educators to ensure that its textbooks are objective, comprehensive, and relevant.

Secondly, the NCERT should consider revising its textbooks to reduce the burden of the syllabus on students. However, the revision should not result in the loss of valuable historical information or distort the history of a particular period. The NCERT should strike a balance between reducing the syllabus and providing a comprehensive understanding of Indian history.

Thirdly, it is essential to promote critical thinking and analysis among students. Rather than merely memorizing facts and dates, students should be encouraged to critically analyze and interpret historical events. This approach will not only help students develop a deeper understanding of history but also promote their analytical and reasoning skills.

Fourthly, it is essential to promote the values of secularism, religious tolerance, and harmony among students. The study of Mughal rulers, particularly Akbar, can help inculcate these values among students. The NCERT should ensure that its textbooks promote these values and provide a comprehensive understanding of their importance in Indian society.

Conclusion

The debate on the removal of some Mughal topics from NCERT textbooks is complex, and there are valid arguments on both sides. While the removal of these chapters may help in reducing the burden of the syllabus on students and ensure that the textbooks are free from political biases, it may also result in the loss of valuable historical information and distort the history of a particular period.

Therefore, it is essential to find a balanced approach to the issue, one that takes into account the academic merit of the chapters, the burden of the syllabus on students, the need for a comprehensive understanding of Indian history, and the promotion of secular values among students. By adopting a balanced approach, the NCERT can ensure that its textbooks provide students with an objective, comprehensive, and relevant understanding of Indian history.

The study of history is essential to understand the present and shape the future. The decision to remove certain Mughal topics from NCERT textbooks should not be taken lightly. It is imperative to understand that history is not just a collection of facts and dates but is a narrative of the past that shapes our present and future. By removing some chapters on Mughal rulers, we risk erasing an important part of our cultural and historical heritage. As a society, we must strive to preserve our history and learn from it, rather than selectively erase it. We must acknowledge the flaws and shortcomings of our past and work towards building a better future.

Education plays a critical role in shaping the minds of the next generation. The NCERT textbooks are the primary source of education for millions of students across India. It is essential to ensure that these textbooks provide an objective, comprehensive, and relevant understanding of Indian history. The decision to remove or retain certain chapters in these textbooks should not be influenced by political biases or ideologies. Instead, it should be based on academic merit, ensuring that students receive the best education possible.

In conclusion, we must remember that history is not just a collection of facts, but a narrative that shapes our present and future. The decision to remove some Mughal topics from NCERT textbooks is complex, and it is essential to find a balanced approach to the issue. While reducing the burden of the syllabus is important, it should not result in the loss of valuable historical information or distort the history of a particular period. As a society, we must strive to preserve our history and learn from it, acknowledging its flaws and shortcomings, and work towards building a better future. It is essential to promote critical thinking and analysis among students, encouraging them to interpret historical events and make informed decisions that shape the world we live in.

ALSO READ: India’s Freedom: The Philosophical Difference between Gandhi and Godse